Food & Drink

Slice of NYC in COS: 11 Must-Try New York Style Pizza Places!

Best New York Style Pizza Places In Colorado Springs

New York City is famous for a lot of things, but perhaps one of the most iconic is its pizza. Thin, crispy crusts, tangy tomato sauce, and generous toppings are all hallmarks of the classic New York slice.

But what if you don't live in the Big Apple? Fear not, because you can still enjoy authentic New York-style pizza right here in Colorado Springs.

Whether you're a transplant from New York or just a pizza lover in search of a great slice, there are plenty of options to choose from in this city.

From hole-in-the-wall joints to sleek modern pizzerias, there's something for everyone. But with so many options, how do you know where to start?

That's where this guide comes in. We've scoured the city to find the best New York-style pizza places in Colorado Springs, so you don't have to.

Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese slice or something a little more adventurous, we've got you covered. So sit back, relax, and get ready to discover some of the best pizza this city has to offer.

1. Slice 420

Slice 420
2501 W Colorado Ave #108, Colorado Springs, CO 80904 (Google Maps)

Slice 420 is a family-owned pizzeria that serves up delicious New York-style pizza. With a commitment to giving back to the community, this restaurant offers a variety of pizza slices that are generously sized and bursting with flavor.

The crust is crispy and the toppings are of high quality. The staff is friendly and accommodating, making the dining experience enjoyable.

Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni or something more unique, like the Greco, Slice 420 has something for everyone.

The prices are reasonable, making it an affordable option for a quick lunch or dinner. If you're in the area and craving some pizza, Slice 420 is definitely worth a visit.

2. Leon Gessi New York Pizza

Leon Gessi New York Pizza
1806 Palmer Park Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80909 (Google Maps)

Leon Gessi New York Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. The crust is both chewy and fluffy, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful.

Their Kitchen Sink pizza is a crowd-pleaser, and their calzones and subs are also delicious.

The restaurant has a cozy and authentic New York atmosphere, and the staff are friendly and welcoming.

Prices are reasonable, and they even have gluten-free options. If you're looking for some of the best pizza in town, Leon Gessi New York Pizza is definitely worth a visit.

3. Poor Richard's Restaurant

Poor Richard's Restaurant
324 1/2 N Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Poor Richard's Restaurant is a must-visit for pizza lovers. Their New York style pizza is crispy and delicious, with a variety of toppings to choose from.

The restaurant also offers vegetarian and gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is cozy, making it a great spot for a casual meal.

With a bookstore and toy store next door, it's a unique and enjoyable destination for families and book lovers alike. Don't miss out on this local gem!

4. Dion's

Dion's
6385 Source Center Point, Colorado Springs, CO 80923 (Google Maps)

Dion's is a casual New York style pizza place that offers specialty pies, subs, and salads.

The staff is friendly and the pizzas are made fresh to order. The Tuscany pizza is a must-try with its fresh ingredients and reasonable price.

The restaurant has a clean and comfortable atmosphere, making it a great spot for a family night out.

While the pizza and salads are good, the lack of beer options may disappoint some customers. Dion's also offers a military discount and a convenient drive-through window for easy pick up.

5. Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

Colorado Springs Pies And Grinders
5490 Powers Center Point #180, Colorado Springs, CO 80920 (Google Maps)

Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is a must-visit pizza place for all New York style pizza lovers.

The restaurant offers a great selection of local beers and wines to pair with their delicious pizzas. The crust is fresh and the toppings are of high quality.

The staff is friendly and provides excellent customer service. The restaurant is clean and has a great ambiance.

If you're looking for a non-chain pizza place that offers fantastic food, then Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is the place to go.

6. Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta

Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta
3113 N Hancock Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (Google Maps)

Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit for pizza lovers. This family-owned restaurant offers custom-made New York-style pizzas that are delicious and affordable.

The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring that your pizza is prepared quickly and accurately.

The restaurant also offers a variety of Italian eats, including pasta dishes and salads. Although there is no seating area, the restaurant offers delivery and takeout options.

If you're looking for a great pizza place in town, Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta is definitely worth checking out.

7. Pizza Time Colorado

Pizza Time Colorado
8794 N Union Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80920 (Google Maps)

Pizza Time Colorado offers a fun atmosphere with a variety of food options beyond just pizza.

The staff is friendly and accommodating, making it a great spot for families and groups. The pizza is the standout item, with a thick crust and fresh toppings that won't disappoint.

Prices are reasonable and there's even a veteran discount offered.

If you're looking for a casual spot for some delicious New York style pizza, Pizza Time Colorado is definitely worth a visit.

8. Duca's Neapolitan Pizza

Duca's Neapolitan Pizza
236 E Cheyenne Mountain Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80906 (Google Maps)

Duca's Neapolitan Pizza serves up some of the best New York-style pizza around.

With a perfectly cooked crust and flavorful sauce, their pizzas are sure to satisfy any pizza craving. They offer a variety of toppings and the option to customize your own pie.

The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is comfortable and casual.

Whether you're dining in or taking out, Duca's Neapolitan Pizza is a great choice for authentic and delicious pizza.

9. Louie's Pizza

Louie's Pizza
1146 E Fillmore St, Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (Google Maps)

Louie's Pizza is a no-frills joint that offers the best New York-style pizza in town.

The pizza sauce has a delicious flavor, and the toppings are of high quality. The crust is cooked to perfection, and the cheesy bread is a must-try.

The staff is friendly and provides excellent customer service. Louie's Pizza also offers gluten-free options, salads, and soda.

The dining area is simple, but comfortable. The prices are reasonable, and the portions are generous. Louie's Pizza is a time-tested pizzeria that is worth a visit.

10. Parry's Pizzeria & Taphouse

Parry's Pizzeria & Taphouse
1268 Interquest Pkwy #100, Colorado Springs, CO 80921 (Google Maps)

Parry's Pizzeria & Taphouse is a top spot for delicious New York-style pizza.

Their extensive beer selection and friendly service make for a great dining experience.

The restaurant also offers a variety of sandwiches, wings, and salads. The upstairs lounge area provides a beautiful view of the mountains.

Parry's Pizzeria & Taphouse is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

11. Borriello Brothers Real New York Pizza

Borriello Brothers Real New York Pizza
215 E Platte Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Borriello Brothers Real New York Pizza offers a delicious and authentic New York-style pizza experience. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, while the toppings are fresh and flavorful.

The lunch special, which includes unlimited slices of cheese, pepperoni, or specialty of the day, is a great deal.

The service is average, but the staff is friendly and welcoming. The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

Prices are reasonable and the portions are generous. Highly recommended for pizza lovers looking for a taste of the Big Apple.