Food & Drink

11 Best Places for Buffalo Shrimp in Colorado Springs, CO

Best Places For Buffalo Shrimp In Colorado Springs

Are you a fan of delicious seafood dishes? If so, Colorado Springs has some of the best places to get buffalo shrimp. Nothing beats fried shrimp tossed in a spicy sauce and served with your favorite dipping sauce.

Whether you're looking for an upscale restaurant or a more casual spot, there are plenty of great options in Colorado Springs where you can enjoy this classic dish.

When it comes to finding the best places for buffalo shrimp, there are certain things to look out for. You want to make sure that the restaurant is using quality ingredients and preparing the food properly. Not all restaurants serve up equally good food and some may even be using frozen shrimp instead of freshly cooked ones!

It's important to do your research before deciding where to eat. Additionally, be sure to check out reviews from other customers and see what they have to say about the restaurant's buffalo shrimp dish.

Once you've found a few restaurants that meet your criteria, it's time for you to go out and try them! With so many great options in Colorado Springs, it shouldn't be too hard for you to find one that serves up mouth-watering buffalo shrimp dishes that will have your taste buds singing with delight!

Read on as we explore some of the top spots in town where you can find delicious buffalo shrimp dishes at their finest!

1. Shuga’s

702 S Cascade Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Sitting in the heart of Colorado Springs, Shuga’s is an eclectic cafe that serves light global fare, creative cocktails and coffee served in a slick and retro-feel room.

The atmosphere is romantic and relaxing, with friendly and accommodating service. The bathroom was clean and well-maintained.

The menu offers something for everyone with a small but fantastic selection of dishes. We ordered the bruschetta board, spicy coconut shrimp soup, two orders of karaage-needs-a-name chicken sandwich (one with the soup and one with jalapeno bacon mac & cheese) – all packed full of flavor in every bite!

Their shrimp soup is some of the best soup I've ever eaten – spicy yet light and creamy.

The el gaucho w/ spicy Brazilian coconut shrimp soup and rufus were delicious. Had a great taste across appetizers, soups, salads and sandwiches. From appetizers to desserts Shuga’s is definitely worth visiting for its inventive flavors on a casual dinner menu!

Fast service, convenient location & parking make it even more attractive. While we wished there was more shrimp (only had 2), overall our experience was very positive!

2. 503W

503 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 (Google Maps)

Diners looking for a unique dining experience and high-quality food will want to check out 503W. This cozy restaurant serves up some of the best buffalo shrimp you’ll ever taste.

The atmosphere is lively and inviting, with a buzzing bar area and creative Asian-inspired gastropub eats.

The menu has something for everyone, from street tacos to shrimp cakes to tuna bowls. Every dish is full of flavor and generally unique – not your typical pub fare! The portions are ample but not over the top big or pretentiously small.

Everything is cooked perfectly, from the crispy chicken to the calamari sauce that really packs a punch. And don't forget about the goat cheese shrimp cakes – they're absolutely delicious!

Service at 503W is cheerful, friendly, and attentive – exactly what you'd expect from a great restaurant.

Prices are very reasonable, with an average of $20 per person; definitely worth it considering how good the food tastes. To top it all off, there's also an extensive craft beer menu that's sure to please any beer lover!

Overall, we had an excellent experience at 503W – great atmosphere, great food, great bartenders!

We'll definitely be back soon to try more of their menu items!

3. Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe

Garden Of The Gods Market And Cafe
616 S Tejon St Suite C, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Walking into Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe, you will be welcomed with a friendly staff and a cozy, clean ambience.

The menu is unique to the style they represent, with large portions in some areas and small in others. All of the staff members went above and beyond to make sure our experience was pleasant!

The food is presented beautifully on the plates and tastes so gourmet. Try their Southern Benedict – it's a little spicy but has excellent flavor. Their buffalo shrimp is definitely a must-try!

The special sauce that comes with it is spicy yet creamy and compliments everything at the table perfectly. It was so good and had the perfect amount of heat/spice. The portion size was huge, big enough for two people to share.

The market area has an impressive selection of prepared foods, meats, soups, salads as well as hot sauces, crackers, pasta jams sauces desserts souvenirs and more – all well worth it & very generous portions!

Admittedly it's a bit pricey but you get what you pay for here – delicious food served quickly (order to delivery took no more than 10 minutes). Overall we had an enjoyable experience at Garden of the Gods Market & Cafe and would highly recommend this place!

4. MacKenzie’s Chop House

Mackenzie’s Chop House
128 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Mackenzie's Chop House is an elegant underground steak and martini spot that offers a warm yet sophisticated wood-and-stone basement setting.

The menu is varied, offering steaks, seafood, and inventive martinis. The lunch specials are cost-effective and filling, making it a great place to take the family or have a business lunch.

The service at Mackenzie's Chop House was top-notch – we were seated, served and able to eat in 45 minutes! Our waitress was knowledgeable about celiac disease and attentive to our needs.

The food was of high quality yet had a confused identity – two steak selections and two fish selections as well as chicken dishes. We had the shrimp pasta which was very good with four jumbo shrimp plus spinach salad with house-made bread. The mussels were fresh and the sauce great.

The atmosphere at Mackenzie's Chop House was very pleasing to the eyes; it can be quite romantic for couples or conversational-promoting for groups of friends or colleagues. Attention to detail was evident in every meal – even the honey mustard dressing tasted homemade!

We also sampled their famous shrimp cocktail which lived up to its reputation: massive shrimp almost as big as my hand! Great drinks, great steaks, and definitely the best shrimp cocktail in town!

5. Streetcar520

520 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Tucked away in a cozy corner of town, Streetcar520 is an inviting and must-visit spot for any food lover.

With its friendly staff, diverse menu and great atmosphere, Streetcar520 offers something for everyone.

The restaurant features a wide range of dishes from falafel to fried chicken, all plated beautifully with wonderful spices. Generous portions come with the shrimp etouffee family dinner while the Mac n cheese and nachos are both delicious and unique.

Buffalo wings are cooked to perfection with plenty of sauce and the shrimp are tender but not rubbery or grainy. The curry sauce is outrageously addictive too! Prices may be a bit higher than other places but you definitely get your money's worth here.

The bar also has an impressive selection of beers, wines and cocktails to choose from plus live music nights that make it even more special.

And if you're looking for modifications on your order like subbing tomato sauce instead of cream sauce or no cheese on top – no problem! The staff will happily accommodate requests like this with no pushback whatsoever.

Overall, Streetcar520 is a great place for anyone looking for good food in a warm environment at reasonable prices.

With its diverse menu options and friendly employees who go the extra mile for their customers, you won't be disappointed!

6. Po’ Brothers

Po’ Brothers
1826 E Platte Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80909 (Google Maps)

A visit to Po’ Brothers is an experience like no other. From the moment you step in, you know you’re in for a treat.

The atmosphere is lively and inviting, with friendly staff that makes it feel like home.

The menu offers a wide selection of Cajun-style seafood dishes – from shrimp po boy to alligator meat and crawfish.

All dishes are cooked to perfection with just the right amount of spice and flavor, making them perfect for even the most discerning palate. Prices aren't bad either, especially considering the portion size and quality.

The owners are extremely hospitable and have a spotless kitchen – they had just passed their health inspection today!

They also offer a variety of fried desserts as well as catering services for events or takeout during these times.

What really sets Po’ Brothers apart though is their customer service – they go above and beyond to make sure everyone feels welcome and taken care of.

The food here is creative, authentic, freshly cooked, delicious and definitely worth waiting 10 minutes for! It's no wonder that so many people come back time after time – it's simply one of the best places to get seafood in Colorado Springs!

7. The Wobbly Olive

The Wobbly Olive
3317 Cinema Point, Colorado Springs, CO 80922 (Google Maps)

Billed as an upscale-casual eatery with a full bar, The Wobbly Olive does not disappoint.

From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere is comfortable and inviting. The green light accents throughout give the place a modern feel.

The menu is small but creative, offering farm-fresh small and large plates with something for everyone. From appetizers like calamari and bruschetta to mains like Mahi Mahi tacos or bacon-wrapped shrimp on a bed of brussel sprout salad, every dish that comes out of this kitchen is cooked to perfection.

Prices are slightly higher than other places but you get what you pay for – delicious food and great service!

The staff at The Wobbly Olive is attentive yet professional without being intrusive. Our waiter was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and gave us great recommendations.

We also appreciated that the chef came out to ask us if everything was alright – it shows how much pride they take in their work.

Overall, we had a wonderful experience at The Wobbly Olive – from drinks to appetizers to our main dishes, everything was top-notch!

Highly recommend if you’re looking for an intimate restaurant with creative cuisine!

8. Chef Bob’s Lobstah Trap

Chef Bob’s Lobstah Trap
5660 Barnes Rd Suite 148, Colorado Springs, CO 80917 (Google Maps)

Oozing with East Coast charm, Chef Bob’s Lobstah Trap is the perfect place for buffalo shrimp.

From the moment you enter, you can smell the aroma of freshly cooked seafood and feel the cozy atmosphere. The restaurant is clean and organized, with plenty of parking available.

The menu has something for everyone – from lobster rolls to fried haddock to house-made chips. But it's their buffalo shrimp that really stands out. Cooked fresh when ordered, these delicious fried shrimp are truly a treat!

The portions may be small but they're definitely worth it; there's nothing quite like the flavor of this unique dish! And don't forget to try their delicious clam chowder – more like a potato soup with a hint of seafood flavor than your typical chowder.

Although prices may be on the high side at Chef Bob’s Lobstah Trap, you won't be disappointed in quality or taste. Plus, they offer great customer service and an atmosphere that feels just like home – making it well worth it!

So if you're looking for an amazing seafood experience in Colorado, head over to Chef Bob’s Lobstah Trap and sample some of their delicious buffalo shrimp today!

9. The Juicy Seafood

The Juicy Seafood
501 Garden of the Gods Rd, Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (Google Maps)

Tucked away in a quiet corner, The Juicy Seafood is the perfect spot for seafood lovers. With a wide selection of seafood dishes, the restaurant offers something for everyone.

The shrimp was good sized and tasted delicious with a rich cocktail sauce with just a hint of spice. Service was friendly and efficient, although it could be faster during peak times. The atmosphere was nice and the restaurant was very clean.

The food selection at The Juicy Seafood is vast, with plenty of options to choose from including Cajun/garlic butter seasoning with medium heat level. Presentation of food is delightful, and the seafood is always fresh with great flavor.

Prices are slightly higher than other similar spots, but it's worth it for the quality that you get in return. Appetizers such as baskets are also available to share among friends or family members while enjoying your meal.

Overall, The Juicy Seafood provides an enjoyable experience with great customer service and excellent food at reasonable prices – definitely worth checking out!

10. Captain D's

Captain D's
1234 E Fillmore St, Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (Google Maps)

Catering to those who crave seafood, Captain D's is a fast-food chain known for its fried shrimp and fish.

With combo meals offering gumbo, funnel cakes, and more, this restaurant is sure to satisfy any seafood lover.

The atmosphere at Captain D's is pleasant and welcoming. The staff is professional and attentive to customer needs.

The restaurant itself is spotlessly clean, with plenty of condiments available that are fresh and well-stocked. There's even a drive-through option for those who don't have time to sit down at the restaurant itself.

The food at Captain D's lives up to its reputation as one of the best places for fried fish and shrimp combos in town. Meals are reasonably priced with options such as a two piece fish with six butterfly shrimp dinner or the deluxe seafood platter with fish, shrimp, hush puppies, and two sides for around ten dollars.

Everything here tastes great — hot and fresh — and there are even options for people with allergies to certain food items.

Overall, Captain D's offers excellent value for money in terms of both quality and quantity of food served here.

With friendly service staff making it an enjoyable experience all around, this fast-food chain has earned its place among the top places to go when looking for a good-tasting seafood meal on the go!

11. Springs Orleans

Springs Orleans
123 E Pikes Peak Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 (Google Maps)

Sitting in Springs Orleans, you immediately get a sense of the New Orleans vibe.

The atmosphere is airy and elegant, with live jazz and special performances hosted regularly. The restaurant specializes in classic Cajun-Creole cuisine.

The menu has all the essentials for lunch, but is limited. Prices are a bit above average, but quality is definitely there to make up for it.

Appetizers range from catfish bites to gumbo fries, while dinner options include po' boy sandwiches and truffle mac & cheese with blackened chicken. My favorite dish was the Gorgonzola Fettuccine with Buffalo-style Shrimp – it was absolutely amazing!

The staff here are friendly and attentive; they help each other out when busy so your food won’t sit around forever.

The desserts could have had more choices but overall I was very happy with my experience at Springs Orleans – great service, great atmosphere, and great food! Highly recommend if you’re looking for an authentic Cajun-Creole restaurant in the area!

Don’t miss out on our Pinterest pin and web story.