Food & Drink

7 Best Places for Key Lime Pie in Denver, CO

Best Places For Key Lime Pie In Denver

Ah, key lime pie. The tart, creamy dessert that is beloved by so many. It's the perfect ending to a meal or a great snack to pick up on the way home from work.

If you're in Denver and looking for the best places to get your key lime pie fix, look no further! In this post, I'll be sharing some of my favorite spots around town for delicious key lime pie.

From classic takes on the dish to unique twists, there are plenty of places in Denver that will satisfy your craving for this citrusy treat. Whether you want something light and refreshing or an indulgent version with whipped cream on top – you can find it all here!

And don't forget about those who prefer their pies frozen – there are plenty of options for that too! No matter what your preference is, I'm sure you'll find something that fits your taste buds perfectly.

So get ready for some serious sweet tooth satisfaction – these are my picks for the best places in Denver to get your fill of key lime pie!

1. Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar

Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar
1539 17th St, Denver, CO 80202 (Google Maps)

Brimming with fresh seafood, cocktails and a relaxed atmosphere, Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar is an upscale chain restaurant with something for everyone. From the fresh, succulent oysters to the generous pours of cocktails, it's easy to see why this place is so popular.

The presentation of each dish is nothing short of artwork and the flavor combinations are fun and creative. The staff are knowledgeable and attentive, ensuring that every customer has a great experience from beginning to end.

The seafood towers range from a good single person meal to some extravagant platters. The crab was fresh and absolutely delicious while the oven roasted tomatoes were sweet and the sauces were smooth.

Diners can also enjoy an amazing Oysters Rockefeller or a perfect key lime pie for dessert – both presented promptly but separately which allows customers to truly appreciate each individual selection without being rushed.

Overall, this spot offers great value for money with quality service and food that's beyond expectation.

With its casual atmosphere yet classy décor, Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar is definitely worth visiting whether you're dining in or ordering takeout!

2. The Pasty Republic

The Pasty Republic
4166 Tennyson St, Denver, CO 80212 (Google Maps)

Crispy crusts, juicy fillings, and a great variety of flavors make The Pasty Republic a must-visit spot for key lime pie lovers. This small shop offers up delicious pasties with fast and friendly service.

The baker creates hearty classic meals wrapped in pastry that can be enjoyed on the go or at home. They also offer dairy-free options with a nice consistency and taste.

The Pasty Republic has an impressive selection of pies to choose from, including peach cobbler, Italian variations, stout variations similar to British steak pie and more.

Prices are very reasonable – they even have an 8 for 1 free deal – so it’s easy to sample multiple varieties at once. Food is always fresh and the chef brings out trays of freshly baked pasties each day.

The atmosphere at The Pasty Republic is relaxed and inviting, making it perfect for grabbing a quick snack or meal.

Plus, the staff are always happy to let customers sample new menu items before ordering! If you’re looking for delicious key lime pie in a chill spot then this is the place for you!

3. Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts

Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts
2325 E 28th Ave, Denver, CO 80205 (Google Maps)

A visit to Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts is an absolute delight! This charming family-owned and operated business offers a wide selection of desserts, including pies, cupcakes, and ice cream.

Their signature key lime pie is a must-try – the creamy custard filling and crunchy crust make it a true treat. The staff are incredibly friendly and accommodating, always willing to go above and beyond to make sure customers have the best experience possible.

The menu also has something for everyone's sweet tooth – from decadent chocolate mousse pies to refreshing blueberry pies.

Each treat is made in-house with high quality ingredients that you can taste in every bite. And if you're catering for an event, they have all sorts of delicious options available for delivery or pick up.

The atmosphere at Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts is cozy yet polished; it's the perfect place to catch up with friends or enjoy some alone time indulging in delicious treats.

Whether you're grabbing your favorite dessert by the slice or ordering a full pie, you'll be sure to leave satisfied!

4. Omonoia Greek Bakery

Omonoia Greek Bakery
2813 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206 (Google Maps)

Sitting in the heart of the city, Omonoia Greek Bakery is a cozy spot to grab a bite or pick up some pastries. With its warm and inviting atmosphere, it's easy to feel at home.

The customer service is friendly and helpful, making it easy to find what you're looking for. Prices are very reasonable for the delicious items offered.

The pastries here are top notch! From their signature Key Lime Pie to their Apple Pie and Walnut Cake, all flavors are perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness.

The Spanakopita is especially flakey with a great blend of spinach, egg and cheese. And don't forget about the delicious Canolis – they're not too sweet which makes them perfect for any occasion!

If you're looking for something more than just pastries, they also offer a variety of cakes that can be pre-ordered if needed.

Their Tiramisu Cake was put together quickly and beautifully last minute for someone's birthday – it only took 15 minutes!

In conclusion, Omonoia Greek Bakery is an amazing place to get some sweets or have lunch with coffee. It has warm atmosphere and friendly staff that make it feel like home no matter who you are or when you come in.

And most importantly, their baked goods are out of this world – definitely worth a visit anytime your in the neighborhood!

5. Maggie and Molly’s Sweet Life

Maggie And Molly’s Sweet Life
2908 E 6th Ave, Denver, CO 80206 (Google Maps)

Housed in an old-fashioned building with a bright and inviting atmosphere, Maggie and Molly’s Sweet Life offers a wide range of delicious desserts.

From cupcakes to brownies, crumb cakes to pies, the bakery has something for everyone. The seasonal offerings are especially popular, like the Palisade Peach crumb cake. All goods are made from scratch and taste amazing.

The staff is friendly and helpful. They were happy to accommodate my request for delivery at the last minute. The cake was delivered on time and it looked great!

Not only that, but it tasted incredible too – rich flavor without being overwhelming and delicate texture that was perfectly iced with little flowers.

The prices are also very reasonable for such high-quality goods. Everything I have tried so far has been delicious – from the key lime pie to their signature cookie cake – all of which were perfect for special occasions or just a sweet treat!

If you’re looking for aesthetically attractive and delicious bakery items at an affordable price then Maggie & Molly’s Sweet Life is definitely worth checking out!

6. Azucar Bakery

Azucar Bakery
1886 S Broadway, Denver, CO 80210 (Google Maps)

Diners looking for a delicious key lime pie should head to Azucar Bakery. This specialty and occasion cake shop offers an array of designs and flavors, as well as tasting appointments.

The presentation is neat and classy, with cakes that are light to eat yet still packed with flavor. Their staff is professional and courteous, always offering friendly service to customers.

The store features a pastry case with a range of standard flavors like vanilla with strawberry filling, lemon with raspberry filling, or chocolate with mouse filling for the layers.

Customers can also order online for easy and quick ordering. Prices are reasonable for the quality of baked goods offered here.

At tastings, guests have the option to try more than one flavor – from wedding cake consultation to satisfying everyday cravings – all at once!

The staff is always friendly and easy to work with; they will do what they can to make customers happy. Azucar also ranks very high in the wedding cake design industry, making it an excellent choice for any special occasion or event!

7. Mermaids Bakery

Mermaids Bakery
1543 Champa St, Denver, CO 80202 (Google Maps)

Ooh la la! Mermaids Bakery is a dream come true for any dessert lover. They offer a wide range of delicious treats, including cupcakes, pies, mini pies, cakes and cookies.

All these treats are made from scratch with the highest quality ingredients. The staff is friendly and accommodating when ordering or picking up your order.

The key lime pie from Mermaids Bakery is to die for! It's moist and flavorful with a light white frosting that's just sweet enough to make it perfect.

They also offer other flavors such as raspberry poppyseed and strawberry lemonade that are equally delicious. Plus, they have a limited selection of gluten-free cupcakes which can be customized with Oreo pieces if desired.

The presentation of the desserts is also top-notch – everything looks so beautiful you almost don't want to eat it!

The prices are great too – very reasonable for what you get in terms of quality and quantity. Plus, the response time is quick considering how busy they usually are.

All in all, Mermaids Bakery offers an amazing selection of desserts at great prices with friendly service and quick response times – definitely worth checking out if you're looking for some delicious treats!

Also, don’t overlook the web story and Pinterest pin versions of this article.