Food & Drink

11 Best Places for Pumpkin Pie in Denver, CO

Best Places For Pumpkin Pie In Denver

Welcome to the Mile High City, Denver! As we transition from summer to autumn, there’s no better way to celebrate the season than with a slice of pumpkin pie.

Whether you’re looking for a classic take on this Thanksgiving staple or something more adventurous, there are plenty of delicious options throughout Denver.

This blog post is your guide to finding the best places in Denver to get pumpkin pie. We’ll provide you with an overview of all the delicious variations available at different bakeries and restaurants around town. From traditional recipes featuring warm spices and creamy custard fillings to creative takes like pumpkin chiffon pies and vegan options, there’s something for everyone in Denver.

Whether you’re looking for a sweet treat after dinner or planning ahead for Thanksgiving dessert, these spots have got you covered! Keep reading to discover all the delectable pumpkin pies that Denver has to offer!

1. The Pasty Republic

The Pasty Republic
4166 Tennyson St, Denver, CO 80212 (Google Maps)

Mouthwatering pastries are the star of the show at The Pasty Republic, a quaint pastry shop in Denver.

This casual joint is known for its traditional English pies filled with meats and veggies that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Prices are a bit steep, but you get what you pay for in terms of quality.

The pasties are made fresh daily and you can also purchase frozen ones to take home or use for an event. There’s an extensive selection of flavors and combinations to choose from, so it’s easy to find something new and exciting each time you visit.

The crust is always flaky yet moist and the fillings are well-seasoned with thoughtful flavors that never disappoint. Plus, they offer dairy-free crust options as well!

The staff at The Pasty Republic is friendly and helpful, offering samples of potential new menu items so customers can see what they’re getting before they buy it.

Service is fast too, making it a great place to grab a quick bite before heading out on an adventure or just relaxing in your favorite spot. If you’re looking for something new or want one of these delicious hand pies, this place is definitely worth checking out!

2. Azucar Bakery

Azucar Bakery
1886 S Broadway, Denver, CO 80210 (Google Maps)

Hands down, Azucar Bakery is the place to go for pumpkin pies! Not only do they offer a wide variety of flavors and styles, but their customer service is top-notch.

From the moment you walk in, you are greeted by friendly staff who are attentive and helpful. The cakes are also beautifully presented with delicate frosting that is nearly whipped cream-like.

The bakery offers an array of flavors from fruity and bright to decadent and rich.

You can even mix and match some of the flavor combinations they offer which makes it easy to find something that will please everyone's taste buds. The prices are also very reasonable making it a great option for any budget.

If you're looking for a special treat or occasion cake, Azucar Bakery has got you covered!

Their selection of specialty cakes is impressive and their tasting appointments make it easy to decide on just the right flavor combination for your event. Plus, they offer online ordering which makes everything even more convenient.

Overall, Azucar Bakery is a great place to get your pumpkin pie fix! From their delicious cakes to their friendly customer service they have everything you need to make your event special. Highly recommend them if you're ever in need of something sweet!

3. Omonoia Greek Bakery

Omonoia Greek Bakery
2813 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206 (Google Maps)

A visit to Omonoia Greek Bakery is a must for anyone in search of delicious desserts. The bakery offers a variety of sweet and savory goodies, all made with the same level of care and attention.

The pastries are warm, inviting, and priced fairly. There's something for everyone here – whether you're looking for a quick snack or a full meal.

The star of the show is the spanokopita, an incredibly flakey pastry filled with spinach, egg, and cheese. It's surprisingly good, huge in size, and not overly sweet like many other desserts found elsewhere.

Besides spanokopita, the bakery also has canolis that aren't too sweet either – perfect for those who don't have much of a sweet tooth. The walnut cake is also worth trying out; it's super moist with orange and spices flavoring it nicely.

The customer service at Omonoia Greek Bakery is always friendly and welcoming; you'll likely walk away feeling as if you've just been welcomed into someone's home! Prices are very reasonable too – most items cost only $4.50 or less – making this spot an ideal place to pop into when you have a sudden craving for sweets or something savory.

There are a few tables if you want to stay but they also do take out business as well! All in all, Omonoia Greek Bakery is an excellent spot to visit when looking for some amazing pastries or lunchtime snacks!

4. French For Sugar

French For Sugar
1201 E Colfax Ave #103, Denver, CO 80218 (Google Maps)

Diners and bakers alike are in for a treat when they visit French For Sugar. This one-of-a-kind bakery has several flavors of pumpkin pies to choose from, all of which are delicious.

The cakes and cupcakes look beautiful and taste great, but at a more affordable cost than many other shops. The presentation is always top-notch quality with fresh ingredients.

The staff is professional, friendly, and accommodating – even offering to write happy birthday messages on cupcakes if requested! Everything here is beautifully crafted with care and attention to detail.

All the goodies have amazing flavor without being overly sweet. The cookies are soft yet flavorful – just the right combination for perfection.

Overall, French For Sugar offers an unforgettable experience that will leave you wanting more! From the delicious treats to the exceptional customer service – this bakery has it all!

5. Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts

Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts
2325 E 28th Ave, Denver, CO 80205 (Google Maps)

Tucked away in a small corner of the neighborhood, Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts is a hidden gem. This family-owned and operated business offers a variety of delicious pies, cakes, and other desserts that are made fresh daily.

The staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating, making it an enjoyable experience every time you visit.

The buttery flaky crusts on the pies make them irresistible, while the crunchy pecans in the filling create a perfect balance of sweet and savory flavors.

The cake selection is also noteworthy with moist layers and creamy buttercream icing that isn't overly sweet. Not to mention their ice cream selection which has plenty of options to choose from!

Whether you're looking for something to share or just want to satisfy your sweet tooth craving, Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream & Desserts is sure to please.

They offer different pie flavors every day along with a variety of other desserts – all made in-house so you can taste the difference from store-bought goods. Their establishment is well-polished, and the service is friendly and timely.

6. Pie Hole

Pie Hole
44 S Broadway, Denver, CO 80209 (Google Maps)

Walking into Pie Hole, you know you are in for a treat.

The decor is interesting and inviting, with an edgy yet comfortable atmosphere. The staff is always friendly and attentive.

When it comes to the pizza itself, Pie Hole does not disappoint. They have a great selection of toppings/combinations and all of them are full of flavor. Their NY-style pizza has a thin and crispy crust and the toppings are fresh and flavorful.

The slices themselves are soft and chewy, with just the right amount of sweetness in each bite. They also offer vegan options that are amazing! Prices are reasonable for the quality of ingredients used – about two bucks or so per slice – so you get what you pay for here!

Pie Hole is also open late at night, perfect if you're looking for a late-night snack or meal option. For only ten bucks, you can get two slices plus a brew – with a tip included You can even take it to go in one of their baby pie boxes if needed.

Overall, Pie Hole offers an awesome experience when it comes to pizza – from the atmosphere to the quality ingredients used in their pies!

7. Petunia Bakeshop

Petunia Bakeshop
3000 W 23rd Ave, Denver, CO 80211 (Google Maps)

Bakery lovers, you must check out Petunia Bakeshop! This small business is located on Federal and it's the perfect spot to grab a coffee and treat.

They have a great selection of both sweet and savory pastries, all of which are delicious. The portions are large and the prices are very reasonable. Plus, their customer service is friendly, warm, and welcoming.

Petunia offers something for everyone with a variety of baked goods including quiches with flaky crusts that melt in your mouth, strawberry cc danish, quesabirria croissants, raspberry iced tea, cheese danish, breakfast sandwiches, coffee drinks, almond croissants, and more!

Their gluten-free section also has multiple options for those looking for alternatives. We tried their poblano-jack croissant which was very flavorful and their zucchini galette was amazing! The cheesecake was delicious – as close to a European style as you can find in the US.

Overall, we had an excellent experience at Petunia Bakeshop! The quality of the food is amazing while still being reasonably priced.

8. Miss Molly’s Bakery

Miss Molly’s Bakery
2600 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206 (Google Maps)

Molly’s Bakery is an absolute must-visit for anyone looking for delicious desserts. The variety of pastries and treats available is remarkable, ranging from calzones to cheesecakes and pastries.

The custard-filled pasticiotti are particularly noteworthy, as the custard itself has a unique and perfect flavor. Their spinach calzone is also worth trying, especially when thoroughly warmed and toasted. Furthermore, Molly's offers a wide selection of hand pies with both savory and sweet fillings.

The staff at Molly’s Bakery are also very friendly and helpful in guiding customers towards the best sweets for them. They were even able to snag me a cake two days before a holiday!

Chocolate lovers will be in heaven here as there is an abundance of options from giant whoopee pies to German chocolate cake to a half brownie/half cookie delights. Carrot cake fans will not be disappointed either – their double layer is heavenly!

In conclusion, Miss Molly’s Bakery offers something for everyone with its delectable selection of pastries and treats that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth cravings.

9. Maggie and Molly’s Sweet Life

Maggie And Molly’s Sweet Life
2908 E 6th Ave, Denver, CO 80206 (Google Maps)

Cakes, pies, and pastries are the stars at Maggie and Molly’s Sweet Life. This casual spot offers freshly baked desserts that are delicious and aesthetically pleasing.

Specializing in brownies, muffins, crumb cakes, fruit pies, cupcakes, breakfast items, and more – all made from scratch with love. The selection of flavors is awesome; their seasonal offerings like Palisade Peach crumb cake are worth the drive to get here.

The customer service is incredibly friendly and accommodating; they take last-minute orders that look as if you ordered them weeks ago. Plus, they offer classes for those who want to learn how to bake like a pro!

Their buttercream frosting can be a bit too buttery for some but overall their cakes taste amazing. Everything was moist and sweetly decorated with detail making it a work of art.

Whether you’re looking for an awesome-looking dessert or just a tasty treat – Maggie & Molly’s Sweet Life has you covered!

Prices are more than reasonable and the quality of their products is top-notch – perfect for any occasion or special event!

10. Mermaids Bakery

Mermaids Bakery
1543 Champa St, Denver, CO 80202 (Google Maps)

Pumpkin pie lovers rejoice! Mermaids Bakery is the place to go for all your pumpkin pie needs. Located in a small shop, this bakery offers a wide selection of cupcakes, pies, mini pies, cakes, and cookies that are all made from scratch.

With a variety of flavors and designs to choose from, you'll be sure to find something that fits your craving. The quality of ingredients used at Mermaids Bakery is top notch and their attention to detail when it comes to their decorative elements really takes the cake!

The staff is always polite and friendly and will go out of their way to accommodate special requests as much as possible. Plus, they have great prices for all their delicious treats.

The cakes are moist with unique flavors like churro that make them stand out from the rest. They also offer cookies that are soft, fresh, and delicious. Plus, they can deliver on time if you need your order quickly. The response time when ordering is also very quick even during busy times which is great for those who need something last minute.

Overall, Mermaids Bakery provides an excellent experience for those looking for pumpkin pie or other desserts in the area. Their quality ingredients combined with their attention to detail make them stand out above the rest!

11. The Cheesecake Factory

The Cheesecake Factory
1201 16th St Mall, Denver, CO 80202 (Google Maps)

Sitting down at The Cheesecake Factory for dinner is always a treat. With over 50 types of cheesecake on the menu, you'll be spoilt for choice and questioning every life decision that led you to this moment.

The American chain restaurant offers sizable portions from a vast menu including signature cheesecake.

The food is consistently fresh and tasty with plenty of vegetarian options too! There's something for everyone – from the appetizer of fresh guacamole & chips to the main dishes and desserts.

The service is usually spot on once seated with friendly, courteous, and professional staff who really want to make your experience as pleasant as possible.

The atmosphere is beautiful and nicely lit, cozy and warm with hearty portions that are well worth the price/quantity and quality of food.

The texture was great – the same quality we've always expected – even though the pieces seemed smaller this time but still equally filling! Value was very good considering it's still a treat to dine here with their wide variety of foods to choose from and tons of desserts.

Overall, dining at The Cheesecake Factory is an enjoyable experience that can't be missed if you have a sweet tooth or just love good food!

Make sure to also check out the web story and Pinterest pin of this article.