If you’re a fan of meatball subs, Colorado is the place to be. With its wide array of restaurants and cafes, it’s easy to find some of the best meatball subs in the country.
Whether you’re looking for something classic or something a little more creative, there’s something for everyone in Colorado.
When it comes to finding the perfect meatball sub, there are a few important things to consider. Topping selection, quality of ingredients and overall atmosphere all play an important role in creating an unforgettable experience.
Fortunately, there are plenty of great options across Colorado that will satisfy your cravings for an amazing meatball sub.
From traditional Italian-style subs to more inventive takes on this classic sandwich, these eateries have everything you need for the ultimate meal experience.
The key is finding one that suits your tastes and preferences – so let's take a look at some of the best places for meatball subs in Colorado!
1. Leon Gessi New York Pizza
Dining at Leon Gessi New York Pizza is an experience in itself. This humble spot has been a long-standing option for New York-style pizza, subs and calzones in warm, laid-back quarters.
The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for enjoying quality food with friends or family. Prices are reasonable and the service is fast.
The menu offers a variety of delicious Italian dishes including pizza, salads, sandwiches, calzones and more. We tried the 16" cheese pie which was hot and fresh with a thin crust that had just the right amount of chewiness to it.
The appetizer bread is really worth the money as well! Other items on our table included a meatball sub and an Italian sub both filled with quality ingredients that were delicious. We also had a Calzone which could have used a bit more meat but was still tasty.
Overall we enjoyed our experience at Leon Gessi New York Pizza – the food was great, prices were reasonable and service was quick!
If you're looking for some authentic Italian eats in New York style then this place should be your go-to spot!
2. Santana’s Vegan Grill
Packed with flavor and texture, Santana’s Vegan Grill is a vegan fast-food restaurant and drive-thru that serves plant-based versions of classic American fare.
From burgers to chicken strips, sliders, and fries – the food here is delicious! The portions are generous and the prices are very reasonable. Plus, their unique drink options are well selected.
The staff at Santana’s are friendly and efficient, providing exceptional customer service every time. The burgers have a nice melted consistency on the hot sandwiches, while the steak/chicken “meats” have an authentic bite to them.
Their Italian sausage is mouthwatering with fried jalapenos, peppers, and mayo. Moreover, all of their other menu items are delicious too!
Overall, Santana’s Vegan Grill is an excellent option for both veg and non-veg friends. The flavors you may miss as a non meat eater can be fulfilled here – making it easy for families in a hurry to get quick yet healthy meals.
Furthermore, they care about their customers as well as their employees which reflects in both their food quality and service provided every time!
3. Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli
A meatball sub lover's paradise, Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli offers a variety of delicious options. From the classic Grinder sandwich to the Dominic meatball sandwich, the options are endless.
The red sauce is especially flavorful and the bread is freshly made Italian bread. There are also several varieties of cheese cake to choose from. The portions are in line with the prices and service is always prompt and friendly.
The atmosphere at Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli gives off a real mom and pop feel, with warm and welcoming staff members that make sure you have everything you need for an enjoyable meal.
They also have a meat counter with quite a few limited variety of meats and cheeses to choose from. All of their dishes use fresh ingredients that give it an authentic flavor that will make you come back for more.
The Lasagna is especially noteworthy as it has a good portion size, full of flavor, well presented, and definitely one of their best dishes on offer!
Don't forget to grab some yummy bread to go with your meal as well! For those looking for high quality sandwiches in an inviting atmosphere, Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli should be your go-to spot!
4. Peppino’s Pizza & Subs
Tucked away in a small corner of the city, Peppino’s Pizza & Subs is an Italian eatery that serves up a variety of delicious food.
The menu includes pizza, sandwiches and other items. The atmosphere is casual and the staff is friendly.
The pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and they offer gluten free options. The toppings are fresh with great seasoning and the crust is tender and chewy.
They also have calzones with meatballs and sausage, which come in junior size.
The sandwich bread is amazing – slightly toasted crust on the outside with a soft inside.
They also offer buffalo chicken pizza for those who like it spicy but it could use some more flavor.
Their delivery service is excellent with speedy delivery times, making it easy to get your meal quickly when you need it most.
Prices are fair for what you get; definitely worth the extra price for such high quality food! Manager cares about customer satisfaction as well which makes this place even better!
5. Pizzeria Leopold
Opinions about Pizzeria Leopold are unanimously positive. The meatball subs here are made from scratch with hand-rolled perfection and a delicious sauce, cheese, and crispy crust.
The bread is fantastic, with an outside that is crisp and inside that is fluffy. Quality is worth the cost, as portions are large and sandwiches are made using the last owners recipe.
The menu highlights include signature pizzas, hot subs, cold subs and salads. Pizza here has a distinct taste compared to almost every pizza tried in Denver.
Staff members go out of their way to make customer experiences great ones, while ingredients used in all dishes are fresh and of high quality. A good tasting sandwich can be had by doubling up on the meat portion size if desired.
The Italian market & deli offers meats, cheeses, pasta & other groceries plus pizza & sandwiches at reasonable prices. Marinated eggplant and marinara sauce is particularly noteworthy when it comes to flavor and texture – definitely worth trying!
Fresh bread from nearby bakery adds even more value to the experience – one that customers keep coming back for time after time!
6. Bono’s Italian Restaurant
Crisp, hot and delicious, Bono’s Italian Restaurant is the place to go for a great meatball sub. With a tangy sauce and plenty of cheese, the taste is unbeatable.
The bread can be a bit soggy at times, but it doesn’t take away from the overall experience. The sandwiches are huge and amazingly tasty. Prices are reasonable and portion sizes generous.
The atmosphere at Bono’s is cozy and inviting with friendly staff that make you feel right at home. Food preparation is done with simple ingredients that are executed very well.
Chicken Marsala was especially good as were their gnocchi in creamy basil sauce. Their 4-cheese pizza was also delicious with an amazing crust and bread that really wowed us!
The steak-and-cheese sandwich here is one of the best around – loaded or made to order with generous amounts of steak – always cooked to perfection!
Desserts here are also top notch so don't forget to leave room for them! Service can run a bit slow during rush hours but it's worth the wait for this delicious Italian restaurant experience!
7. Grinder Sandwich
Hands down, Grinder Sandwich is the place to go for a delicious and unique sandwich experience.
The restaurant offers freshly made sandwiches with locally sourced ingredients, including marinated meats and breads from a local bakery. The staff is friendly and courteous, they greet you warmly and remember your name.
The menu features an array of delicious options, from their signature Petey meatball sub to vegetarian sandwiches. All of the ingredients used are fresh and high quality.
Plus, customers can customize any sandwich to their liking. The Cream of Broccoli soup is also worth trying! Prices are reasonable considering the quality of the food served here.
Atmosphere wise, Grinder Sandwich has a relaxed vibe that makes it perfect for lunch or dinner with friends or family.
Everything is made in-house so there’s usually a short wait while your sandwich is being made but it’s totally worth it! All in all, this place offers great food at reasonable prices – definitely one of the best sandwich shops in town!
8. Lou’s Italian Specialties
Lous Italian Specialties is an upbeat neighborhood outpost for sandwiches, paninis, salads and specialty grocery items. It has a cheerful vibe that makes it a great spot to grab a bite or pick up some groceries.
The deli is stocked with high-quality meats and cheeses, ensuring delicious sandwiches and paninis every time. The soup is very seasoned and flavorful, making it the perfect starter for any meal. The chicken cutlet sandwich was especially noteworthy for its freshness and lightness.
The star of Lou's Italian Specialties are their meatball subs which come close to tasting like homemade meatballs. The sauce is one of the best around and the portions are generous.
The bread used in the subs is also fresh and delicious, adding to the overall experience. Other noteworthy dishes include their spaghetti and chicken parmesan which were both incredibly fresh with quality ingredients used throughout each dish.
The prices at Lou's Italian Specialties are very fair considering the quality of ingredients used in each dish. They also have a bakery that makes all of their breads from scratch so you can be sure you're getting top-notch sandwiches every time you visit them.
Additionally, they offer pasta sauce to go so if you're looking for something to take home after your meal then this might be your best option!
Overall, Lou's Italian Specialties offers an excellent dining experience with high quality ingredients at reasonable prices.
Their service may be a bit slow but it's worth the wait once you sample their delicious food!
9. South Jersey Subs
Sitting in the small, cozy restaurant of South Jersey Subs, one can feel the warmth and love that has been put into this family-run business.
The owner puts his heart and soul into every meal he makes, from the freshly cooked meatballs to the perfect sauce. Every sandwich is made with fresh ingredients, ensuring quality and flavor to each bite.
The sandwiches are a bit smaller in size than other sub shops, making them easy to eat despite the generous portions of sandwich meat.
Prices are slightly higher than fast food joints but totally worth it for the quality you get. The staff was very friendly and efficient with their service so that you don’t have to wait long for your order.
The Italian sub is especially noteworthy as it comes with plenty of cold cuts and flavorful toppings like mushrooms, onions, peppers, and cheese.
The bread is fluffy yet not too dense or dry like many other sub shops now offer. For sides they have delicious fries that make a great accompaniment to any sandwich order!
Overall South Jersey Subs offers an excellent experience whether you’re ordering takeout or dining in their restaurant.
With fresh ingredients put together by an owner who takes pride in his work, this place will definitely leave you wanting more!
10. Mr Lucky’s Sandwiches
Mister Lucky’s Sandwiches is a sandwich shop offering a wide variety of hot and cold deli sandwiches with specialty toppings.
Their meatballs and chili are deliciously hand crafted, with the bread having great texture and the meats being flavorful. The toppings are always fresh, making for a perfect combination of meats and cheeses.
The subs are ready on time and delicious, with great value for money – the half size usually fills up even gluttons.
The quality ingredients also make it stand out from other sub shops in town, as their meats are roasted in house rather than off the shelf junk. There’s also Chipotle mayo that has a tiny kick to it which adds to its flavor.
The customer service at Mister Lucky’s is outstanding too. They take pride in their restaurant and have friendly people working behind the counter who will help you make your meal choices.
The seating area is plenty large enough for customers so food comes out on time without waiting too long or feeling cramped inside the establishment.
Overall, Mister Lucky’s Sandwiches is an unassuming counter-serve offering quality ingredients and delicious sandwiches at reasonable prices – making it an ideal spot for classic subs as well as specialties like BLAT or Santa Fe French Dip that will leave you mouthwateringly satisfied!