Food & Drink

14 Best Spots for Meatball Sub in Colorado Springs, CO

Best Places For Meatball Sub In Colorado Springs

Welcome to Colorado Springs, the beautiful city nestled in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains. Whether you're a local or visiting for a few days, one thing is certain: you'll want to sample some of the great food this town has to offer.

And what better way to do that than by sampling some of Colorado Springs' best meatball subs?

Meatball subs are an American classic and come in all shapes and sizes. From simple sandwiches with just cheese and sauce, to ones loaded with all sorts of toppings, there's something for everyone.

In Colorado Springs, you can find some truly delicious meatball subs that will make your taste buds happy. Whether you're looking for an old school classic or something a little more adventurous, here are some of the best places in town to get your hands on one!

1. Slice420

2501 W Colorado Ave #108, Colorado Springs, CO 80904 (Google Maps)

Sitting in the heart of the city, Slice420 is a small but cozy restaurant offering delicious pizzas and subs.

The atmosphere is laid back and inviting, with an outdoor patio for guests to enjoy. The prices are reasonable and the service is fast and friendly.

The pizza at Slice420 is made from quality ingredients with a unique flavor profile that sets it apart from other places.

The crust has a hint of honey sweetness that balances out the savory flavors of the cheese, sauce, and toppings. The four cheese pizza is especially delicious!

The meatball subs are also worth trying as they have homemade meatballs with a unique orange sauce that packs a nice spice kick.

All of it comes together perfectly in their freshly made dough which gives it an excellent texture and flavor. Toppings such as cheese selections are top notch here too!

Slice420 offers great value for money – plenty of food at affordable prices, fast service, friendly staff, and delicious pizza with unique flavors make it well worth visiting!

2. Leon Gessi New York Pizza

Leon Gessi New York Pizza
1806 Palmer Park Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80909 (Google Maps)

Tucked away in a quiet corner of town, Leon Gessi New York Pizza is the perfect spot for a delicious meal.

With its classic New York style atmosphere and reasonably priced menu, it's no wonder why locals keep coming back.

The pizza here is made with fresh ingredients and generous toppings.

The crust is soft and flavorful, while the sauce has a great balance of sweetness and acidity. Calzones are also on offer, as well as subs and salads.

The staff at Leon Gessi New York Pizza is friendly and attentive to customer needs.

Their customer service is top-notch and they go out of their way to make sure everyone has an enjoyable experience.

The Italian Buffalo Bread is one of the standout items on the menu – filled with mushrooms, it's crunchy on the outside but soft inside.

There's also plenty of beer to choose from if you're looking for something to wash down your meal with!

Leon Gessi New York Pizza offers delicious food at great prices in a cozy atmosphere that will make you feel right at home!

3. Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli

Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli
985 Garden of the Gods Rd # A, Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (Google Maps)

Featuring family-run service and high quality Italian food, Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli is a great spot for a meatball sub. The portions are reasonable and the prices are in line with them.

The atmosphere is friendly and the workers are attentive and polite. There's also a meat counter with various options of cheese and meat to choose from.

The sandwiches here are well crafted, with just the right amount of spices, meats, and temperature. Their signature Dominic or Grinder sandwich will take your breath away in its depth of flavor. The bread isn’t freshly baked but it still tastes quite fresh. The red sauce is delicious too! Even their classic spaghetti with meat sauce was quite good and fresher than expected.

Don't forget to grab some yummy bread on your way out! Their tiramisu is also noteworthy – it's one of the best I've had! And if you're looking for something sweet, their selection of cheese cakes is excellent.

Whether you're looking for a hearty sandwich or authentic Italian food, Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli has got you covered!

4. Grinder Sandwich

Grinder Sandwich
656 Peterson Rd, Colorado Springs, CO 80915 (Google Maps)

A great neighborhood sandwich shop, Grinder Sandwich offers a wide selection of locally sourced sandwiches and grinders.

The menu is abundant with specialty sandwiches, salads, and soups that are both fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, with polite staff providing excellent service.

The signature dish at Grinder Sandwich is the meatball sub “The Petey” or Pete. It features freshly made meatballs in house marinade which are then served on locally-baked rye bread lightly toasted with sauerkraut, dressing and cheese.

The sandwich has generous portions of meat making it very filling yet satisfyingly tasty. It also comes with pepperoncinis and peppers on the side adding a great touch to the overall flavor of the sandwich.

Aside from the classic Petey sandwich, other specialty items on their menu include Italian sandwiches, Philly cheese steak, Reuben sandwiches as well as Cream of Broccoli soup which was noted to be particularly good and fresh by customers who have tried it before.

Prices are reasonable for what you get – generous servings that do not skimp on quality ingredients like meats and cheeses.

Grinder Sandwich provides an excellent experience – from friendly service to high-quality ingredients that make up their dishes; all presented in a relaxed atmosphere giving off an overwhelming sense of hospitality that keeps customers coming back for more!

5. South Jersey Subs

South Jersey Subs
1726 Brookwood Dr, Colorado Springs, CO 80918 (Google Maps)

Hands down, South Jersey Subs is a must-visit spot for anyone searching for a delicious sandwich. From the moment you walk in and see the friendly staff, you know you're in for something special.

The owner makes all of their meatballs and sauces with love, which adds an extra level of flavor that can't be found anywhere else.

The subs are generously filled with high-quality meat and served on delicious bread. Prices are comparable to fast food but the quality is much higher – both hot and cold sandwiches are equally great.

The veggie subs come with plenty of toppings, making them a great option for vegetarians or those looking to cut down on their meat intake.

The customer service here is top notch – they take their time to ensure each sandwich is made fresh with quality ingredients.

And if that wasn't enough, they also offer fries, onion rings and milkshakes – including strawberry milkshakes made with real strawberry stuff made in house!

South Jersey Subs offers an awesome sandwich experience in a fast paced diner atmosphere at very reasonable prices. You get generous portions of high-quality ingredients cooked with love by the owner himself!

Whether you're looking for a classic Italian sub or something different like steak and egg, this place has it all – plus unbeatable customer service!

6. Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

Colorado Springs Pies And Grinders
5490 Powers Center Point #180, Colorado Springs, CO 80920 (Google Maps)

Oozing with flavor, Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is the perfect spot for a delicious pizza or a hearty grinder. The pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and the crust is always light and crispy.

The sauce is just right – not too much, not too little – giving it a great balance of flavor. They also don’t skimp on the toppings or cheese, making each bite full of flavor.

The meatball parm grinder is one of their signature dishes and it’s definitely worth trying! The sausage has a unique flavor that stands out from other restaurants in the area.

They also offer classic Philly Cheese steaks as well as chicken grinders, all served on bread shipped in from Philadelphia.

The atmosphere at Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is very enjoyable with fast service to boot! Prices are quite reasonable for what you get – generous portions of quality food at a fair price.

Plus they have plenty of choices when it comes to spirits to enjoy while you eat your meal. All in all, this place gets 10 out of 10 stars for its tasty food, friendly service, and great value!

7. O’furry’s

3552 N Academy Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80917 (Google Maps)

Catering to those looking for a quality sandwich experience, O’furry’s offers generous portions of fresh and tasty meatballs, vegetables, and bread.

The menu is broad and customizable, so you can make the perfect sandwich for your taste. The staff is friendly and quick to serve up hot food with a smile. Prices are reasonable and portions are large.

The signature Philly cheese steak sandwich is made with fresh steak cooked to perfection on soft bread. The flavors combine to make a delicious sandwich that rivals any other in the area.

There's also plenty of options when it comes to customization – from adding mushrooms or fries to choosing your own combination of toppings – allowing you to craft your own perfect meal every time. And if you're looking for something lighter, there's always the mushroom version which is just as good but without all the meat!

Lastly, they offer delivery so if you don't feel like leaving the house you can still enjoy their delicious sandwiches right at home!

O’furry’s offers an excellent experience in terms of quality food, great service and reasonable prices – definitely worth trying out if you're in the mood for a Philly cheese steak or some really tasty onion rings!

8. Pizza Time

Pizza Time
8794 N Union Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80920 (Google Maps)

Pizza Time is a great place to get delicious pizza, subs, and other Italian food. The atmosphere is inviting and the service is excellent.

The prices are reasonable for the quality of food delivered in a timely manner.

The pizza has an authentic homemade taste with intense seasoning on the sauce that makes it savory.

The mushrooms were fresh with a deep mushroom flavor, while the mozzarella sticks had tons of cheese in them. The salad was also tasty with extra toppings added for more flavor. The cheesy bread was especially flavorful due to its garlicky taste, and their calzones were huge – possibly the best around!

They also offer online special deals like large cheese pizzas and cheesy bread for only $17.99 which is great value for money! Plus their peppers had a nice kick to them along with good flavor that can be hard to find elsewhere.

Pizza Time offers great food at an affordable price with friendly service in a casual atmosphere – definitely worth checking out!

9. Fillmore Pizza Kitchen

Fillmore Pizza Kitchen
3150 N Chestnut St, Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (Google Maps)

Walking into Fillmore Pizza Kitchen, one can immediately tell that it is a place that takes pride in its cleanliness and atmosphere.

The restaurant offers a variety of pizza options, from classic pepperoni to specialty white pies. The crusts are cooked to perfection and the toppings are fresh and plentiful.

The prices are affordable and customers can expect to leave feeling stuffed. It is worth noting that the dough in the center of most pizzas can be soggy, but this does not detract from the taste.

Aside from pizza, Fillmore Pizza Kitchen also offers lasagna, meatball subs, salads, garlic knots, dips and desserts made from scratch in their kitchen.

The customer service here is outstanding – even when dealing with a busy establishment – with friendly waiters who go out of their way to make sure customers have an enjoyable experience.

Wine pairings for dips or starters are also available upon request. A great deal to check out is the $10 lunch special which includes two pizzas and a pitcher of margarita.

Fillmore Pizza Kitchen offers an excellent dining experience with delicious food at an affordable price point coupled with top-notch customer service – making it well worth checking out while visiting the area!

10. Trivelli’s Hoagies

Trivelli’s Hoagies
4547 Austin Bluffs Pkwy, Colorado Springs, CO 80918 (Google Maps)

Packed with flavor and fresh ingredients, Trivelli’s Hoagies is a great spot for all your sandwich needs. The Italian sausage is like being back east, and the bread is soft and chewy. They offer a range of options from their signature cheesesteak to other meatball subs.

The cherry peppers and oil on the sandwiches are delicious, and the wings are crispy with flavorful buffalo sauce. You can also customize your order to include jalapenos, olives, onions, mushrooms or any other toppings you prefer.

The staff at Trivelli’s Hoagies is friendly and accommodating, making sure that everyone gets in and out quickly without compromising on taste or quality of food.

Their portions are generous while still being easy on the budget. Even if you don’t have time to eat in-house you can still enjoy their delicious hoagies through takeout service.

If you haven’t been to Trivelli’s Hoagies yet then it's definitely worth a try!

With great customer service, delicious food at an affordable price point this place will not disappoint!

11. Louies Pizza

Louies Pizza
4815 Barnes Rd, Colorado Springs, CO 80917 (Google Maps)

Budget-friendly and delicious, Louies Pizza is the perfect spot for a quick bite. The restaurant offers a variety of pizzas, subs, salads, wings and pastas that are all made with fresh ingredients.

The meatball sub is especially noteworthy – it features juicy meatballs on top of toasted garlic butter parmesan crust with tomato slices added for extra flavor. The cheesey bread here also deserves special mention; it's crunchy, cheesy and best of all – it's only five dollars!

The customer service at Louies Pizza could use some work but the prices more than make up for it. Delivery is always timely and the food is always hot when it arrives.

In addition to pizza and subs, customers can also enjoy baked pasta with marinara sauce – definitely recommend trying this dish out!

Louies Pizza is an excellent spot for budget-friendly meals that will leave you satisfied every time.

From their delicious meatball sub to their flavorful cheesey bread and baked pasta dishes – there's something here for everyone!

12. Sport Clips Haircuts of Colorado Springs

Sport Clips Haircuts Of Colorado Springs
7543 N Academy Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80920 (Google Maps)

Sporting Clips Haircuts of Colorado Springs is a great place to get a delicious meatball sub. They offer an array of sauces from mild to hot, so there's something for everyone!

Their sandwiches are made with the freshest ingredients and have the perfect combination of flavors. The bread is always soft and the fillings are generous. The staff is friendly and helpful, making sure orders are prepared correctly and quickly.

The atmosphere at Sport Clips Haircuts of Colorado Springs is relaxed and inviting. There's plenty of seating, so you can enjoy your meal in comfort.

Sport Clips Haircuts Colorado Springs offers a great experience with delicious subs that won't disappoint.

With over 20 sauces to choose from and generous portions, it's definitely worth a visit!

13. Jersey Mike's Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs
1710 E Woodmen Rd, Colorado Springs, CO 80920 (Google Maps)

Tucked away in a small strip mall, Jersey Mike's Subs is a casual, counter-serve sandwich chain that serves up jumbo subs filled with cold cuts and toppings. The staff is friendly and welcoming and the atmosphere is pleasant. The food here is top notch, with fresh meats and veggies as well as freshly sliced meats for each order.

Customers can customize their sandwiches to their liking with various toppings available. Prices are not cheap but better than most other sandwich joints. The catering comes with lots of toppings, making it an ideal choice for larger gatherings or events.

Another great thing about this place is the speed of service – they make sure you get your sandwich quickly without compromising on quality. They also have discount specials going on which makes it even more appealing to customers looking for value-for-money deals.

Jersey Mike's Subs is an excellent choice for anyone looking for a quick yet delicious meal!

14. Schlotzsky's

2381 N Academy Blvd Suite 101, Colorado Springs, CO 80909 (Google Maps)

Featuring a relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff, Schlotzsky's is a great place to enjoy a delicious and unique meal. The counter-serve chain serves deli fare such as the Original sandwich, specialty pizzas, salads, and more.

Their signature sandwich bread is incredibly fresh and flavorful. The sandwiches are made with quality ingredients that really complement each other. The giant size sandwiches are enough to feed two people easily!

The tomato basil soup is thick and creamy while their Mac & Cheese is also amazing. They also offer hot sauces on the tables for those who want to add some extra flavor to their meal. Prices are reasonable considering the quality of food you're getting.

Service can be slow at times but overall it's satisfactory. Cleanliness of the restaurant could be improved as tables were not always cleaned off quickly enough but this wasn't too much of an issue for us during our visit.

In conclusion, Schlotzsky's offers great food at a good price in an enjoyable atmosphere with friendly staff members ready to serve you up something delicious!

Make sure to take a look at our Pinterest pin and web story as well.