It's time to talk tuna salad – one of the most beloved lunchtime staples in Colorado.
Whether you like it with a side of crackers or just as is, there's nothing quite like a delicious bowl of tuna salad.
But where should you go to get the best? With so many restaurants and eateries throughout the state, it can be hard to decide.
Well, fear not! We've done all the hard work for you and compiled a list of the top places for tuna salad in Colorado.
We've taken into consideration many different factors when creating this list, such as freshness and taste of ingredients, overall presentation and atmosphere, and customer feedback.
So, no matter what type of experience you're looking for or what kind of ingredients you prefer in your tuna salad, there's sure to be something on our list that will please your palate!
1. Butterhorn Bakery & Cafe
Bakery & Cafe Butterhorn is a cozy spot for cafe fare and desserts. It features a patio, lattes, brunch cocktails, and baked goods, as well as a wide selection of tasty meals.
The food here is outstanding – fresh, hot, and with a great variety of options for vegetarians. We had tuna salad croissant which was served timely and was delicious. The portion size was large enough to share with friends or family. Prices are reasonable too.
The service at Bakery & Cafe Butterhorn is friendly and professional; the staff is quick to respond to customers' needs. Everything from the food, service, people, and atmosphere were top-notch!
We also tried their tomato basil soup, which was thick, chunky, and full of flavor – definitely worth trying! In addition to that they have lots of fresh baked sweets like sticky buns that are simply divine!
All in all, Bakery & Cafe Butterhorn offers an excellent dining experience with delicious food at reasonable prices – definitely worth visiting if you're ever in the area!
2. Turtle Boat
Mouthwatering tuna salads await at Turtle Boat! This small poke bar offers build-your-own bowls with locally sourced ingredients.
The decor is modern yet inviting, featuring local art, and the staff are friendly and accommodating.
The build-your-own bowls offer plenty of choices for all kinds of diets, including vegan, gluten-free, and health food options. There’s a wide variety of toppings and proteins to choose from, including fresh fish like snapper, trout, and salmon as well as traditional tuna.
The portions are a bit on the small side but the flavor more than makes up for it – the classic tuna is marinated with house sauce and topped with scallions and sesame seeds.
The prices are fair for the amount of protein included in each bowl. The online ordering system is also incredibly efficient so you can get your food faster!
All in all, Turtle Boat offers an amazing selection of poke plates that emphasize local sustainable food – definitely worth checking out!
3. Humboldt Kitchen + Bar
Tucked away in a hip, urban-chic locale, Humboldt Kitchen + Bar offers an upscale atmosphere and a market-fresh New American menu with a focus on seafood.
The restaurant looks recently updated and is very clean and comfortable. The service is excellent – our waiter was kind and attentive with other staff checking in regularly.
The lunch menu is reasonably priced with plenty of variety to choose from including salads, sandwiches, fish tacos, mussels, and more. We had the tuna tartare which was absolutely delicious – fresh ingredients prepared skillfully with no fishy taste!
The salmon sandwich was also amazing – crispy onions on top of a savory layer of cheese sauce atop a bed of butter lettuce on a delectable toasted bun.
For dinner, there are plenty of options ranging from $20 entrees all the way up to market price Filet & NY Strip. We tried the mussels, crab cake, and scampi which were all delicious – no fishy taste here either!
Desserts are small but satisfying; we tried the calamari salad which had lots of greens piled on top for added flavor.
Overall, we had an enjoyable experience at Humboldt Kitchen + Bar – good food selection, consistent top-quality meals, and service, reasonable prices for what you get, and great atmosphere make this place worth visiting.
4. Maggi’s Kitchen
Catering to those looking for a relaxed atmosphere and generous portions, Maggi’s Kitchen offers great quality food at an unbeatable price.
The restaurant is clean and well-decorated, making it a pleasant place to dine. The menu offers some classic dishes alongside fun, unique options. Service is efficient and attentive, with the staff being friendly and helpful.
The food itself is delicious with generous servings that are sure to fill you up. From the classic BLT sandwich to the Bacon Southwestern Skillet, there’s something for everyone here.
Everything tastes fresh and flavorful without being overly salty or greasy like in many other breakfast joints. Prices are cheap but you still get a hearty serving no matter what you order. The hash browns taste homemade, and the country fries are golden crispy nuggets of joy!
Overall, Maggi’s Kitchen is an excellent option for those looking for good food at an affordable price in a relaxed atmosphere.
Not only do they have great-tasting dishes but also provide large portions that won't leave you hungry! For a nice dinner out or just passing through town, this place should be on your list of places to visit!
5. Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar
Walking into Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar, the atmosphere is relaxed and stylish. The menu offers a wide selection of seafood dishes, creative cocktails, and other options.
The servings are nicely proportioned and presented with flair. Everything is made fresh with high-quality ingredients and seasoned to perfection.
The Yellowtail Tuna is especially noteworthy, full of flavor, and served with a variety of sauces to choose from. The crab cakes are moist and flavorful with an amazing hollandaise sauce.
If you're looking for something different, their octopus entrée is tender and delicious. For those who prefer lighter fare, the burrata salad is fresh and flavorful. Fries are hand-cut for extra crispness!
Service at Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar was friendly yet professional; cocktail knowledge was excellent as the server explained each dish thoroughly upon ordering.
Prices may be a bit steep for some but compared to other cities it's actually quite reasonable for the level of quality you get here. Overall, it's an enjoyable experience that's well worth the price
6. HiLo An American Eatery
Diners at HiLo An American Eatery can expect to indulge in a homestyle meal that is both delicious and comforting. The menu offers a variety of pasta and seafood dishes, as well as familiar desserts.
Appetizers are made from scratch and come highly recommended, particularly spicy tuna tartar, burrata, lobster ravioli, and banana bread pudding. Entrees include chicken marsala and tuna tartare, cooked to perfection and served with great presentation.
The charcuterie board could be improved by offering higher quality meats for an extra $10 cost. The atmosphere at HiLo is warm and inviting with clean lines and well-dressed staff.
It is an ideal spot for a casual lunch or dinner date with family or friends. Service is friendly yet efficient and the portions are generous enough to share with others.
Overall, diners will find themselves impressed by the quality of food offered at this eatery for an affordable price!!
7. Yampa Sandwich Company
Oozing with freshness and flavor, Yampa Sandwich Company is the place to go for a delicious, unique tuna salad sandwich. With an extensive selection of hot and cold sandwiches, there's something for everyone.
The staff is friendly and professional – they take their time to make sure you get exactly what you want. The ingredients are all fresh and in reasonable proportions – a half-size sandwich leaves you satisfied without feeling too full or unable to finish.
Yampa provides an array of condiments including mustard, mayo, pickles, and more – all adding up to the perfect sandwich. They also offer breakfast sandwiches at $5 all day long so you can start your day off right!
And if that wasn't enough, they have both indoor and outdoor seating available so you can enjoy your meal in a relaxed atmosphere.
Overall, Yampa Sandwich Company offers great quality food with excellent service at reasonable prices. Their menu has something for everyone no matter what type of sandwich or salad you're after.
Whether it's breakfast or lunch they've got it covered! So, if you're looking for a deli that serves up delicious tuna salad sandwiches then Yampa Sandwich Company is definitely worth checking out!
8. Cafe de France
Housed in a quaint shopping center, Cafe de France offers an extensive American breakfast and lunch menu. The setting is tranquil, and the staff is friendly. With an array of options from eggs to crepes to waffles, breakfast is sure to be delicious.
For lunch, the steak was comparable to Ruth Chris and the stuffed salmon was excellent. The Oh La La sandwich is a must-try – it’s a big club on a homemade croissant served with tasty chips and a small fruit bowl. Prices are mid-range, but the chefs know their stuff!
The restaurant also has great sandwiches, salads, and entrees in a casual yet elegant setting that is comfortable and relaxing at the same time. There are multiple options for breakfast served at lunchtime as well as large portions of fresh dishes prepared perfectly. Customers line up outside this cute cafe for its affordable prices and outstanding service – food comes quickly but always tastes delicious!
Wheelchair access is also available with very accommodating staff members who do a great job with their to-go packaging. Cafe de France is family owned and provides quite a diverse menu that serves up luscious meals presented in colorful enticing ways that will leave your taste buds satisfied!
9. Smokin Fins
Smoakin Fins is a seafood restaurant located in the heart of town. The atmosphere is inviting, and the staff is friendly and professional.
The menu is diverse, offering fresh seafood dishes such as tuna, salmon, scallops, halibut, shrimp, and more. The portions are generous and the food tastes great.
The Seared Scallops with Ahi tuna ($21.99) was delicious – the fish was cooked perfectly and had a great flavor profile.
The Crab Baked Shrimp ($19.99) was also excellent – it was light but satisfying at the same time. For a starter we tried their deviled eggs appetizer which came with a tiny bit of lobster – it was pricey but worth it!
For sushi lovers there's plenty to choose from – try their mango tango sushi to start followed by the Fins mule for wetting your palate then finish up with one of their flavor-packed tacos for an unforgettable experience!
Overall, Smoakin Fins offers great food in an inviting atmosphere at reasonable prices making it worth visiting again!
10. Colorado Craft Social
Packed with unique flavors and a great atmosphere, Colorado Craft Social is the perfect spot for a night out. Located in a trendy strip of restaurants, bars, and shops, this eatery offers elevated pub grub and local libations.
The menu features gourmet burgers, salads, and sandwiches that pair perfectly with local craft beers and cocktails.
The food here is simply amazing! Every dish is made with fresh ingredients and has its own unique flavor. The portions are not huge, but each bite packs an incredible punch of flavor.
The steak was small but more than made up for its taste. For seafood lovers, the tuna salad was particularly good — the fish was cooked to perfection with an excellent batter balance so you could really taste it in every bite!
The atmosphere at Colorado Craft Social is relaxed yet classy. There's plenty of seating both inside and out on the street side patio area complete with comfortable outdoor furniture to enjoy your meal or drinks al fresco style.
The music playing throughout creates a pleasant ambiance while the fresh flowers on each table add to the overall charm of this place.
Overall, if you're looking for great food and drinks at fair prices then Colorado Craft Social should be your go-to spot!
With its delicious flavors and cozy atmosphere it's sure to be an enjoyable experience no matter what occasion you're there for!
11. Rudy’s Little Hideaway Restaurant
Rudy’s Little Hideaway Restaurant is a casual Tex-Mex cantina with a patio. It offers an authentic Mexican menu and breakfast selections in an adobe-style building, complete with a bar and outdoor seating. The prices are very reasonable, and the portions are generous.
The food is freshly prepared with flavorful ingredients, making it easy to take leftovers home for later. The chips and salsa are especially noteworthy – the chips are fried onsite and lightly salted, while the salsa has great flavor but isn't overly spicy.
The guacamole also seems to be freshly made, as it's creamy and full of flavor. Even the beans have good flavor despite not being particularly thick or hearty.
The staff is friendly and helpful, although service can be a bit slow at times due to how popular the restaurant is.
Overall, Rudy’s Little Hideaway Restaurant offers good value for money for its tasty Mexican fare in an inviting atmosphere that makes it easy to linger over your meal or drinks long after you've finished eating.
With its extensive menu selections ranging from traditional dishes to more creative ones, there's something here for everyone – including those looking for vegan or vegetarian options!
12. Lazy Dog Restaurant & Bar
Featuring a relaxed, lodge-chic atmosphere, Lazy Dog Restaurant & Bar is a casual spot for global comfort eats. With a broad selection of dishes, the menu offers stir-fries, pot roast & pasta.
The tuna salad bowl is definitely worth trying here – it's perfectly cooked with fresh ginger which makes it super fresh and interesting. Plus, the portion size is generous, and the price is totally reasonable for such great food.
The establishment was clean and pleasant, and the customer service was above average in the bar area. The calorie count is also listed on the menu which is always nice to have access to when making decisions about what to order.
Great options like grilled chicken Caesar salad or seared Ahi tuna dinner are available at good prices too. We decided to split the cobb salad, which was big, thoroughly mixed, and super fresh – plus there wasn’t any extra left over at all so that was nice!
For appetizers try their hummus plate or goat cheese – both were flavorful and unique additions to our meal experience. Burgers were tasty as well as their pancakes with bacon which had a mellow flavor that pleased everyone at our table.
Fries were another highlight – they're incredibly good but be aware that sandwich portions can be slightly smaller than expected. All in all, we had no complaints about our experience here! It closes late (midnight) so you can come anytime for great food quality and service even at end of the night!
13. Ai Sushi & Grill
Ai Sushi & Grill is a great place to go for sushi and other Japanese cuisine. The food is cooked and seasoned perfectly, with consistently fresh ingredients from the rice to the fish.
The staff is friendly, and the prices are reasonable. There's always something new on the menu, making it a fun experience every time you visit.
The sushi rolls are large and packed with flavor, with each one having its own unique twist.
Tempura veggies in appetizers are cooked in a thick tempura batter layer that is super delicious, as they use freshly changed oil to ensure top-quality dishes.
The atmosphere at Ai Sushi & Grill is intimate and relaxing, with smaller hibachi tables creating an enjoyable setting for customers.
Service is always fast and friendly – they take care to explain each dish as it's being prepared – making it worth the visit whether you're dining in or taking out. Prices may be higher than in other places, but the quality of food makes up for it tenfold!
Overall, Ai Sushi & Grill offers great food with excellent service in a fun atmosphere at reasonable prices – definitely check this place out if you get a chance!